Injunction does not limit any sale of service for any Oracle products or restrict service deliverables Rimini Street provides its clients
LAS VEGAS, November 9, 2018 – Rimini Street, Inc. (Nasdaq: RMNI), a global provider of enterprise software products and services, and the leading third-party support provider for Oracle and SAP software products, today issued the following statement regarding the recent court ruling on the motion to stay the injunction:
"Once again, Oracle's apparent fear of Rimini Street's strong value proposition and compelling 'Business-Driven Roadmap' alternative that has been successfully implemented by a growing list of more than 2,600 clients since 2005, including more than 150 Fortune 500 and Global 100 clients, appears to be fueling its misleading and increasingly desperate marketing campaign.
As usual, Rimini Street will provide the facts, while Oracle provides the misleading bluster.
Third-Party Support Lawful to Offer and for Oracle Licensees to Purchase and Use
The U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ("Court of Appeals") found that Rimini Street 'provided third-party support for Oracle's enterprise software, in lawful competition with Oracle's direct maintenance services.'
Oracle Failed in Almost All of Its Claims
The Oracle v. Rimini Street trial concluded in 2015. Oracle ultimately lost 11 out of its 12 claims, prevailed on just one claim of 'innocent' infringement, was found to have suffered no lost profits or customers resulting from the 'innocent' infringement, and CEO Seth A. Ravin was exonerated of all claims. The 'innocent' infringement finding by the jury means that Rimini Street did not know and had no reason to know that its former processes were infringing.
In 2016, following the Oracle v. Rimini Street trial, the U.S. District Court ("District Court") issued an overly broad and vague injunction against Rimini Street. The injunction purported to address former support processes that are no longer in use, and that have not been used since July 2014 at the latest.
Rimini Street immediately appealed the injunction to the Court of Appeals, citing numerous legal flaws. In January 2018, the Court of Appeals vacated that flawed injunction and remanded the matter back to the District Court for reconsideration. On August 15, 2018, the District Court imposed substantially the same flawed injunction that the Court of Appeals had previously vacated, and Rimini Street immediately moved to again appeal the injunction.
On November 5, 2018, the Court of Appeals affirmed the briefing schedule for the appeal, but denied Rimini Street's motion for a stay of the injunction pending resolution of the appeal. The Court of Appeals provided no reason for its denial of the stay motion, and the order does not address the merits of Rimini Street's appeal. Rimini Street looks forward to once again having the legally-flawed injunction vacated on appeal.
No Limit on the Sale or Delivery of any Services for Oracle Products
Like the original injunction that was vacated by the Court of Appeals, the renewed injunction does not limit any sale of service for any Oracle products or restrict service deliverables Rimini Street provides its clients, but rather defines the manner in which Rimini Street may continue to provide support services for certain Oracle product lines.
Quotes from Oracle Speak for Themselves
Oracle's actions, including its misleading marketing campaign, may be fueled by a deep set of beliefs and entitlements regarding customers. In fact, the following quotes from Oracle senior executives provide further insight into Oracle's apparent contempt for its customers and arrogance as a software vendor.
"Let the bastards dream of reducing their maintenance fees." – Juan Jones, Oracle SVP, Customer Support Services, Global Support Renewal Sales1
"…[maintenance]…is a very profitable part of our business…it is really impossible for us to actually spend our way through it." – Safra Catz, Oracle Co-CEO 2
"…we always get more money." – Safra Catz, Oracle Co-CEO 3
Rimini Street Brings Value and Choice to Clients
Rimini Street has spent 13 years disrupting the enterprise software maintenance business, and we continue our mission to bring our needed services, value and choice to even more software licensees around the world. Enterprises need a support service that empowers IT to meet today's business requirements with a 'Business-Driven Roadmap,' enables innovation agility, maximizes ROI and creates competitive advantage. By switching to Rimini Street's award-winning support, clients can achieve all of these objectives and also enjoy premium services such as full support for all customizations and add-ons at no extra cost.
Oracle Will Be Held Accountable
Rimini Street plans to hold Oracle accountable for any illegal or anticompetitive activity, as it is doing presently with its claims against Oracle filed in a separate lawsuit brought by Rimini Street against Oracle in 2014, Rimini Street v. Oracle, which is pending in the District Court and expected to go to trial in 2021 or later."
1 Oracle Corp. v. SAP AG, No. 4:07-cv-01658-PJH, Dkt. No. 1235 (Trial Tr. vol. 8) at p. 111 (N.D. Cal. June 9, 2013).
2 Oracle Corporation Q2 2009 Earnings Call https://seekingalpha.com/article/111502-oracle-corporation-f2q09-qtr-end-11-30-08-earnings-call-transcript?part=single
3 Oracle Corporation Q2 2013 Earnings Call https://seekingalpha.com/article/1072011-oracle-management-discusses-q2-2013-results-earnings-call-transcript?part=single