Four Challenges with ERP Vendor-led AI Roadmaps & How to Solve Them

Eric Helmer
SVP & Chief Technology Officer
5 min read

Skeptical about AI promises from ERP vendors? Rightly so. We’ve uncovered four primary challenges with ERP vendor-led AI roadmaps. Here’s how to solve them.

CIOs have a tough balance to strike: On one hand, they’re tasked with maintaining a large number of applications—research from Salesforce shows that in 2023 organizations were using 1,061 different applications—in varying stages of age, all the while maintaining interoperability and security and reducing overall spend.

On the other hand, they must look to the future state of the business with an eye toward innovation and investment in new technologies like artificial intelligence (AI). While savvy CIOs bring both business and technology acumen to the table, the most successful follow a business-driven IT roadmap, not one handed to them by their ERP vendor. Especially when it comes to AI.

AI requires a shift in mindset

Being in control of your IT roadmap is a key tenet of what Gartner calls composable ERP, an approach of “innovating around the edges” which often requires a mindset shift away from monolithic systems and instead toward assembling a mix of people, vendors, solutions, and technologies to drive business outcomes. And nothing necessitates this shift more than AI.

AI is a generation-defining paradigm shift in the way the world works and lives. The technology has made tidal waves in society, as more than 180 million ChatGPT users tap the fastest growing app for everything from writing term papers to debugging code. And, as explained in Rethinking ERP Reimplementation in the Age of AI, AI is causing significant impact on enterprises worldwide.

While vendors wield the promise of AI as a forcing function for reimplementation, customers who comply with vendor-dictated AI roadmaps likely face four significant challenges:

Challenge 1: Roadmap limitations & delays

How do SAP and Oracle stack up in terms of AI features and functions? In this nascent field, do they have the right technologists, engineers, and product developers to support continuing growth? Are they on the bleeding edge of this technology or are they simply following the pack?

While they certainly could become powerful AI players, successful organizations need flexibility, and should be able to select from AI industry leaders for technologies—beyond their ERP ecosystems—that meet business needs today, adopt technology from industry AI leaders that can easily plug into multiple databases across your entire enterprise. Why limit your enterprise’s innovative potential to the speed of a big ERP vendor?

Will Henshall, a writer for Time magazine, reports that AI progress over the past 10 years has been nothing short of staggering. His article notes that over the past decade, AI’s performance has exceeded that of humans when it comes to speech recognition, image recognition, reading comprehension, language understanding, and common-sense completion.

With such rapid development of this technology, your enterprise must have the flexibility to choose the right AI vendor to deliver the right AI solution at the right time in order to drive the best business outcomes. And while SAP and Oracle could emerge as major AI players, there’s a lot of green field out there. Your organization must direct a business-driven IT roadmap to stay ahead of the curve.

Challenge 2: Leaving on-premises data behind

For AI algorithms to be successful, they need a massive amount of historical data to draw from. As Gene Marks, a contributor to Forbes wrote, “For AI to do its job it needs to use data.” Remember the “garbage in, garbage out” adage: The more clean data available to an AI algorithm, the more predictive and fine-tuned the results will be.

Henshall’s article in Time echoes the importance of data for training AI: More than half of the AI models Henshall analyzed since 2020 have training sets of 100 million or more data points. “In general, a larger number of data points means that AI systems have more information with which to build an accurate model of the relationship between the variables in the data, which improves performance,” he writes.

With the high price of cloud storage, customers reimplementing on the vendor’s SaaS cloud might not take all their on-premises historical data with them. We often see organizations migrating only a few years’ worth of data, potentially leaving 10 or more years of data behind—the very data that’s the lifeblood of AI.

There is no denying the fact that with more historical, clean data, the more accurate predictive analytics and data correlation can be. The value of the ERP in AI is the data that it contains, and that already exists today within the on-premises systems. It’s best to ingest the relevant, clean, and accurate data from ERP and other systems into a centralized external AI model for best results.

Challenge 3: ERP vendors’ AI setups only look at data in the system

Vendor-embedded AI typically can only work with ERP data. But there are many data stores across an organization that are independent of the ERP system that should be included in any enterprise AI implementation. So, leaving AI to a single monolithic ERP vendor makes little sense. The good news is that there’s a better way.

You can adopt technology from industry AI leaders today that can easily plug into multiple databases across your entire enterprise This flexibility speaks to the power of having a composable ERP, especially one with a robust data orchestration layer. Making your data accessible across your organization will not only benefit your employees but also unlock new potential for more powerful AI algorithm use inside your organization.

Challenge 4: Loss of license ownership risks cost increases & shrinkflation

In addition to leaving your customizations and data behind, reimplementing on-premises ERP functionally to the subscription cloud could mean leaving your leverage of software license perpetual entitlement behind, which can lead to out-of-control costs and shrinkflation.

According to recent financial estimates from Deloitte, many companies that have moved to cloud have incurred complex software licensing issues and costs that can reach as much as 24 percent of total information enterprise technology spend; even after initial TCO analysis, “…many organizations still encounter a cost explosion when the actual migration begins, in part because they were unaware of the licensing requirements for cloud, which can include licensing transfer, purchasing, and visibility issues.”

Turns out shrinkflation—the tactic of reducing the size of a product and either keeping the price the same or increasing it—is not only taking a bite out of your candy bar, but also taking a bite out of your cloud. Research by Vertice finds that more than 24% of businesses have been hit by SaaS shrinkflation during the past 12 months, where cloud vendors are charging the same price for reduced functionality.

Examples of SaaS shrinkflation include non-cumulative pricing, reduced discounting, and feature bundling/unbundling. Vertice advises that to be in a strong negotiating position, you should start due diligence 6-8 months before renewal. But ultimately, to secure the best possible price you need leverage. And without the leverage of software license ownership, considerable cost and shrinkflation risks persist.

Ready or not, the AI revolution is here

I think Bill Gates is spot on when he stated that, “The development of AI is as fundamental as the creation of the microprocessor, the personal computer, the Internet, and the mobile phone. It will change the way people work, learn, travel, get health care, and communicate with each other. Entire industries will reorient around it.”

The volume and velocity of innovative AI technologies is happening at breakneck speed—a pace that likely many ERP vendors will be unable to keep up with. That’s why it’s imperative for organizations to focus on business-driven IT roadmaps, innovating around the edges of their ERP, and solve the challenges that ERP vendor-led AI roadmaps present. Timing is of paramount importance; successful organizations must act quickly to innovate around the edges and outpace the competition.

Learn more: Discover how Rimini Street can help you reallocate resources to further innovation, gain competitive advantage, and accelerate growth.

Eric Helmer

SVP & Chief Technology Officer

Eric Helmer is an information technology executive with 25 years of experience and  proven leadership delivering strategic corporate IT transformational projects. He has a strong track record in designing and implementing technical, complex enterprise technology initiatives that provide real return on investment, competitive advantage, and growth for companies.

Mr. Helmer has a broad consulting background with firms such as Linium, ADI Strategies, and The Hackett Group, where he has delivered successful IT projects throughout the U.S., the U.K., India, the UAE, Singapore, and Thailand.

As Chief Technology Officer at Rimini Street, Eric is charged with advising clients on strategic innovative initiatives that align with financial, technical, and functional long-term corporate goals across various applications including Oracle, SAP, IBM, and Microsoft.  These initiatives are designed to maximize the effectiveness of their mission-critical enterprise software systems.

Before joining Rimini Street, Mr. Helmer was a vice president at Velocity Technology Solutions, where he led the application services team in delivering transformational cloud and IT solutions for Oracle enterprises.

He is a published author, Oracle ACE alumni and a sought-after, award-winning industry speaker in Oracle conferences. He also has served on many board of directors including the Oracle Developer Tools User Group (ODTUG).

Mr. Helmer holds a Master’s degree in business administration and a Bachelor of Science degree in computer science.

More from Eric Helmer

Rethinking ERP Reimplementation in the Age of AI
Blog
Rethinking ERP Reimplementation in the Age of AI
Eric Helmer
Eric Helmer
SVP & Chief Technology Officer
3 min read

You want to innovate with AI, but your ERP vendor mandates a cloud reimplementation, leaving your customizations and data behind? Instead, choose a better way to maximize potential, gain flexibility, and reduce risk; here’s how. Whether viewed from a lens of doom and gloom or hype and hope, the reality is that Artificial Intelligence (AI) […]

AI Potential Meets ROI Pragmatism: 3 Crucial Questions Every CIO Should Ask
Blog
AI Potential Meets ROI Pragmatism: 3 Crucial Questions Every CIO Should Ask
Eric Helmer
Eric Helmer
SVP & Chief Technology Officer
5 min read

As the volume and velocity of new AI technology accelerates, the pressure on IT leaders to implement AI at any cost is all too real. But there’s a better way: Look before you leap by first asking these three key questions. If you had to name 2023’s single-most impactful and disruptive technology, you’d need just […]

How to Evolve IT Systems into Innovation Engines
Blog
How to Evolve IT Systems into Innovation Engines
Eric Helmer
Eric Helmer
SVP & Chief Technology Officer
3 min read

When vendor-driven and customer-driven technology roadmaps are in close alignment, the results can be almost magical. Unfortunately, for most organizations that’s rarely the reality as they’re often left struggling to achieve innovation that their vendors are supposed to enable. IT leaders are all too familiar with this cycle: Up-and-coming vendors mature or get acquired and […]

Is an Integrated ERP Suite or a Composable ERP Strategy Right for You?
Blog
Is an Integrated ERP Suite or a Composable ERP Strategy Right for You?
Eric Helmer
Eric Helmer
SVP & Chief Technology Officer
5 min read

A composable ERP strategy is gaining traction among IT leaders Today’s business climate is rife with economic uncertainty that is causing IT leaders to do more with less while still innovating to support the business. It’s a seemingly impossible dilemma: how to use innovation to drive business outcomes while being restrained by a reduced budget? […]

Configuration Vs. Customization When Adopting a Composable ERP Strategy
Blog
Configuration Vs. Customization When Adopting a Composable ERP Strategy
Eric Helmer
Eric Helmer
SVP & Chief Technology Officer
5 min read

Rimini Street CTO Eric Helmer looks at whether enterprises should customize or configure their ERP system in this latest post in his composable ERP series. Enterprises that look to satisfy most business requirements know that they must modify their out-of-the-box ERP systems. By making adjustments to their SAP or Oracle ERP system, an enterprise can […]

What is a Composable ERP Strategy and How Does It Benefit Organizations?
Blog
What is a Composable ERP Strategy and How Does It Benefit Organizations?
Eric Helmer
Eric Helmer
SVP & Chief Technology Officer
5 min read

The days of the monolithic ERP system are numbered. Many businesses are tired of confining their business practices to those purely defined by SAP and Oracle. Instead, companies are seeking an outcomes-based approach, selecting an optimized mix of vendors and technologies to help them best achieve their goals. The era of the composable ERP is […]

Guiding Principles for Developing a Composable ERP Strategy
Blog
Guiding Principles for Developing a Composable ERP Strategy
Eric Helmer
Eric Helmer
SVP & Chief Technology Officer
4 min read

A composable ERP strategy helps enterprises innovate and become nimbler. Rimini Street CTO, Eric Helmer, highlights four key principles of composable ERP. Many CIOs are shifting their ERP strategy to a composable model To drive innovation and become more agile, many organizations are abandoning a monolithic ERP solution in favor of a composable ERP strategy. […]

Business man walking with his head in a digital cloud
Blog
A Move to IaaS Hybrid Cloud With no Pitfalls? Yes, It’s Possible.
Eric Helmer
Eric Helmer
SVP & Chief Technology Officer
2 min read

Transitioning to a cloud Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS) is a subject we hear in conversations with IT leaders a lot these days. The talk usually contains equal parts readiness and reluctance: how to balance the excitement of moving to the cloud with the dread of scrapping the status quo infrastructure? It’s a tripping point for many. But […]

Not Ready to Move to Cloud ERP? You’re Not Alone
Blog
Not Ready to Move to Cloud ERP? You’re Not Alone
Eric Helmer
Eric Helmer
SVP & Chief Technology Officer
3 min read

Most organizations today have planned an IT roadmap that takes advantage of cloud resources and deployment models. However, that does not mean buying every cloud product a vendor places on its product roadmap or following the exact route and timing the vendor prescribes. Many companies we work with at Rimini Street have made the choice […]